Best Baby Gates
Fifteen baby gates compared on price, mounting, stair use, width and height, from the $27.99 Toddleroo Supergate Ergo to the Dreambaby Mayfair. Read our take
At a glance
| Option | Price | Mounting | Gate Style | Stair Placement | Fits Openings | Gate Height | Material |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $44.98source | Pressure-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Bottom of stairs onlysource | 29–38.5source | 30source | Metalsource | |
| $99.99source | Hardware-mountedsource | Configurable panelssource | 0–192source | 28source | Metalsource | ||
| $29.99source | Pressure-mountedsource | Barrier (no door)source | 26–42source | 23source | Woodsource | ||
| $27.99source | Hardware or pressuresource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 26–42source | 26source | Plasticsource | ||
| $79.99source | Hardware-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 28.68–47.85source | 31source | Metalsource | |
| $69.99source | Freestandingsource | Configurable panelssource | 38.5–192source | 26source | Plasticsource | ||
| $49.99source | Pressure-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Bottom of stairs onlysource | 29–38source | 28source | ||
| $99.99source | Pressure-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Bottom of stairs onlysource | 29–47source | 36source | ||
| $69.99source | Pressure-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | 29.5–36.5source | 30source | Metalsource | ||
| $59.99source | Hardware-mountedsource | Retractablesource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 0–55source | 35.4source | Mesh fabricsource | |
| $139.99source | Hardware-mountedsource | Configurable panelssource | 33.5–147.5source | 29source | |||
| $99.95source | Hardware-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 27–42.5source | 29.5source | Metalsource | |
| $132source | Hardware-mountedsource | Retractablesource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 0–52source | 34source | Mesh fabricsource | |
| $69.95source | Hardware-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 24.75–42.5source | 30.5source | ||
| $79.99source | Hardware-mountedsource | Walk-through doorsource | Top and bottom of stairssource | 31–46source | 32.5source | Metalsource |
Our take
For the top of a staircase, pick a gate that screws into the wall: the KidCo Safeway at $69.95 is built for exactly that, with a stop pin that keeps it from swinging out over the steps. For an ordinary doorway, a pressure gate does the job without drilling, and the Safety 1st Easy Install Auto-Close at $49.99 shuts and latches itself behind you.
The real split in this table is how a gate is held up. Pressure gates like the Regalo Easy Step, the Dreambaby Liberty and both Safety 1st gates wedge into the frame and come out in seconds, but every maker that addresses it says never at the top of the stairs. Hardware gates like the Cardinal Gates Stairway Special, the Ingenuity Stairway+, the Toddleroo Easy Swing & Lock and the two retractables usually take a drill and leave holes, and they are the ones rated for the top step. The rest of the table is about width: a standard gate covers roughly 29 to 42 inches, while the Regalo Super Wide, the Toddleroo Superyard Classic and the Dreambaby Mayfair Converta are panel systems that stretch across an open-plan room.
Our picks
- Cheapest gate for doorways and stairs: Toddleroo by North States Supergate Ergo. $27.99, the lowest price in this table, for a 26 to 42 inch plastic gate that pressure-mounts in a doorway or screws in for the top of the stairs.
- Top of the stairs: KidCo Safeway Top of Stair Baby Safety Gate. A $69.95 hardware gate built for the top step, 30.5 inches tall and fitting 24.75 to 42.5 inch openings.
- Doorways without drilling: Safety 1st Easy Install Auto-Close Baby Gate. $49.99, pressure-mounted for 29 to 38 inch doorways, with a door that closes and latches on its own.
- Retractable on a budget: Dreambaby Glide 'N Hide Extra Tall Retractable Baby Gate. $59.99 for a mesh gate that covers openings up to 55 inches, with 35.4 inches of mesh, and rated for stairs when screwed in.
- Widest openings: Regalo 2-in-1 Super Wide Safety Gate & Play Yard. Eight 24-inch panels reach up to 192 inches, or close into a freestanding play yard.
Pressure-mounted or hardware-mounted baby gate
Five gates here are pressure-only: the Regalo Easy Step, the Evenflo Position & Lock, the Dreambaby Liberty and both Safety 1st Easy Install gates. They cost from $29.99 to $99.99, need no drill, and come out without tools when you want the doorway back. Regalo and Safety 1st print the same warning on their pages: never at the top of the stairs, because a child leaning on a tension gate can push it out.
The single-opening hardware gates run from $59.99 for the Dreambaby Glide 'N Hide to $132 for the Retract-A-Gate, with the KidCo Safeway at $69.95, the Toddleroo Easy Swing & Lock and the Ingenuity Stairway+ at $79.99 each, and the Cardinal Gates Stairway Special at $99.95 in between. The wide panel systems that screw to the wall cost more: $99.99 for the Regalo Super Wide and $139.99 for the Dreambaby Mayfair Converta, the most expensive gate here. The Toddleroo Supergate Ergo is the one gate sold to do both: North States says it may go at the top of the stairs only when you install the included hardware.
Swing door, retractable mesh or no door at all
Most gates here have a door you open with one hand and walk through. The two retractables, the Dreambaby Glide 'N Hide and the Retract-A-Gate, instead roll a mesh screen back into a housing, so nothing is left across the floor when the gate is open. The Evenflo Position & Lock has no door: at $29.99 and 23 inches tall it is a lift-out barrier for occasional use, the shortest gate in this table.
How tall a gate needs to be for a climber
Heights in this table run from 23 inches for the Evenflo to 36 inches for the Safety 1st Easy Install Tall & Wide. Most standard gates sit around 28 to 31 inches. If you have an early climber, the Safety 1st Tall & Wide at 36 inches, the Dreambaby Glide 'N Hide at 35.4 inches of mesh and the Retract-A-Gate at 34 inches of mesh are the tallest options, while the Toddleroo Superyard Classic and the Supergate Ergo stand at 26.
Measure the opening before you buy
A gate's width range is the one figure that decides whether it fits at all, and several are narrower than they look. The Dreambaby Liberty fits only 29.5 to 36.5 inches without extensions, and Regalo notes that the Easy Step leaves a gap between 32 and 35 inches unless you add a separate 4-inch extension. The widest single-panel gate here, the Toddleroo Easy Swing & Lock, covers 28.68 to 47.85 inches.
The options in detail
Regalo Easy Step Walk Thru Safety Gate
Regalo's best-known gate: an all-metal pressure gate with a 16-inch door you walk through, aimed at ordinary doorways. It comes with a 6-inch extension in the box, but Regalo warns there is a gap between 32 and 35 inches that needs a separate 4-inch extension. Regalo's own store lists it but does not sell it directly, so the price shown is Walmart's for the white version. Like every pressure gate here, it is not for the top of the stairs.
Regalo 2-in-1 Super Wide Safety Gate & Play Yard
Eight hinged 24-inch metal panels that you can stretch across a very wide or oddly angled opening, or close into a freestanding play yard. A walk-through door is built into one panel. It is the widest span in this table out of the box, but at 28 inches it is also one of the shorter gates. Regalo does not sell it directly, so the price shown is Walmart's for the black version; the white one pictured was listed for less but out of stock there.
Evenflo Position & Lock Adjustable Wood Baby Gate
The classic diamond-lattice wood gate: no door, no hardware, just a panel you wedge into a doorway with a lift-and-lock bar and take out to pass. Evenflo itself pitches it as a basic gate for the simplest jobs, and at 23 inches it is the shortest gate in this table, so a tall or climbing toddler can get over it. The price shown is for the darker Farmhouse finish pictured; Evenflo sells the plain natural wood finish for a few dollars less.
Toddleroo by North States Supergate Ergo
A light plastic gate made in the USA that most people use as a pressure gate in a doorway, but it ships with the hardware to screw it in, and North States says only that hardware-mounted version is safe at the top of the stairs. There is no walk-through door: you unlock the handle and lift it out, or mount it to swing. Low price and low height, 26 inches, make it a grandparents'-house or travel gate more than a main gate.
Toddleroo by North States Easy Swing & Lock Gate Series 2
A steel gate you screw into the wall that swings fully out of the way when you don't need it, with a swing-direction control so it never opens out over the stairs. It covers one of the widest ranges of any single-panel gate here, about 28.7 to 47.9 inches, with no threshold bar to trip on. North States notes it does not close on its own, and its own store showed it out of stock when we checked.
Toddleroo by North States Superyard Classic
Less a gate than a portable fence: six pre-connected plastic panels that stand on their own as a play area of about 18.5 square feet, or open out as a long barrier. It folds up with a carry handle, which is why it shows up at campsites and grandparents' houses. At 26 inches tall it suits crawlers better than determined climbers.
Safety 1st Easy Install Auto-Close Baby Gate
A pressure gate for doorways whose door swings shut and latches by magnet behind you, with a red-to-green indicator that shows when it is locked. Wall cups stay on the wall so the gate itself lifts out when you don't need it. Safety 1st is plain that it belongs between rooms or at the bottom of the stairs, never the top.
Safety 1st Easy Install Tall & Wide Walk Thru Baby Gate
The taller, wider sibling of Safety 1st's auto-close gate: 36 inches high and adjustable up to 47 inches without extensions, in a decorative finish with an arched top. It is still a pressure gate, so it is for doorways, wide hallways and the bottom of the stairs. Safety 1st pitches the extra height at keeping pets out as well as children.
Dreambaby Liberty Easy Close Metal Baby Safety Gate
A metal pressure gate for doorways and hallways with a door that can be set to stay open when you are passing through a lot, and a one-hand latch. Out of the box it fits a narrow band of openings, 29.5 to 36.5 inches, but Dreambaby sells extensions that take it to 151 inches. Its page does not say anything about stairs.
Dreambaby Glide 'N Hide Extra Tall Retractable Baby Gate
A mesh screen that pulls across an opening up to 55 inches and rolls back into its housing when you are done, so nothing sits in the walkway. It has to be screwed in, and Dreambaby's own answer is that it can go at the top or bottom of stairs when hardware-mounted, set back from the top step. It is also rated for outdoor use, and it is the least expensive retractable here.
Dreambaby Mayfair Converta 3-in-1 Play-Pen Gate
Six modular panels, one of them a walk-through door, that you arrange as an extra-wide gate, a play pen, or a guard around a fireplace. As a straight barrier it spans 33.5 to 147.5 inches, and the wall-mounting hardware is in the box. It is the most expensive gate in this table, and Dreambaby notes the usable span depends on how you lay the panels out.
Cardinal Gates Stairway Special Safety Gate (SS-30)
An aluminum gate Cardinal has made since 1996 that screws into the wall and can be mounted at an angle of up to 30 degrees, which helps when a stud is not where you need it. It opens both ways, with an optional stop so it cannot swing out over the stairs. A wood version exists with a different width range; the figures here are for the aluminum one.
Retract-A-Gate 52-Inch Retractable Baby Gate
An American-engineered retractable mesh gate that rolls into a 3-inch tube when open, and the maker says it is verified by the Baby Safety Alliance for both the top and bottom of stairs, which few retractables claim. Its 34-inch mesh is among the tallest here. A 72-inch model costs $162 for very wide openings.
KidCo Safeway Top of Stair Baby Safety Gate
KidCo's long-running hardware gate for the top of the stairs, with a stop pin that keeps the door from swinging out over the steps and quick-release hardware so the gate lifts off its mounts when you don't need it. A mounting template is in the box. It also works in hallways and doorways, and it is rated 4.94 out of 5 from 16 reviews on KidCo's own store.
Ingenuity The Stairway+ 46W Series Baby Gate
A metal walk-through gate built for staircases, the gate the maker also labels Summer by Ingenuity. Its dual installation kit fixes it to a wall or to most square and round banisters, with no drilling on square ones. The door swings open across the whole width of the gate, there is no threshold bar to trip on, and a stop on the latch keeps the door from swinging out over the steps. The maker's own store has only one review so far, a one-star complaint that the hinge side would not fit the mounting pegs, and its product copy gives two width ranges (31 to 46 and 32 to 48 inches), so measure before you buy.
How we researched this
We read each maker's own product page for every gate and recorded the price, mounting, stair guidance, width, height and material with the sentence each value came from. The set covers the main kinds of gate a family chooses between: pressure doorway gates, hardware stair gates, retractables and wide panel systems from Regalo, Evenflo, Toddleroo by North States, Safety 1st, Dreambaby, Cardinal Gates, Retract-A-Gate, KidCo and Ingenuity. Left out: gates sold only through Amazon, Munchkin gates (we could not find their pages on Munchkin's own site), and the Summer extra-tall gate, whose page had been taken down.
A blank cell means the maker's page does not state that detail: several makers do not say whether a gate can go on stairs, and a few do not name the material. Prices are the makers' listed prices, except the two Regalo gates: Regalo does not sell from its own site, so those prices are Walmart's listings. Prices change often, and some gates were out of stock on the maker's store, so check the current price and the stair rating on the box before you install.














