Best Coolers Compared

19 coolers compared on measured ice retention, weight, true capacity and price, from the $55 Coleman Classic Series 52 to the $475 Yeti Roadie 60. Read our take

At a glance

OptionPriceTypeConstructionCapacityWeightCold Drink DaysCan Capacity
$325sourceHard-sidedsourceRotomoldedsource35source29.6source4.5source54source
$395sourceHard-sidedsourceRotomoldedsource56source30.8source5.3source74source
$425sourceWheeledsource45.4source26.6source7.5source77source
$475sourceWheeledsource59source30.7source6.9source98source
$229sourceHard-sidedsourceInjection-moldedsource49source21.6source6.3source61source
$269sourceHard-sidedsourceRotomoldedsource64source35.4source6.1source96source
$139sourceHard-sidedsource28source11.6source3.8source38source
$300sourceHard-sidedsourceRotomoldedsource48source26.2source5source78source
$230sourceHard-sidedsourceRotomoldedsource59.2source30.3source6.7source90source
$400sourceWheeledsourceRotomoldedsource54.6source36.6source5.9source76source
$130sourceHard-sidedsourceBlow-moldedsource118source18source5source186source
$85sourceHard-sidedsource76source13.6source4.6source114source
$55sourceHard-sidedsourceBlow-moldedsource44source9.4source4.4source74source
$75sourceWheeledsourceBlow-moldedsource52source12.5source4.6source90source
$85sourceWheeledsourceBlow-moldedsource62.3source13.8source5.1source96source
$200sourceSoft-sidedsourceSoft fabricsource44.2source4.5source3.3source63source
$325sourceBackpacksourceSoft fabricsource21.2source5.2source4source36source
$70sourceSoft-sidedsourceSoft fabricsource20.5source3.6source2.3source30source
$145sourceBackpacksourceSoft fabricsource33.2source3.6source2.5source56source

Our take

If the cooler has to keep drinks cold the longest, the Yeti Roadie 48 held them below 50°F for 7.5 days, the best result in this table, but it lists at $425. The Xspec 60qt came closest at 6.7 days for $230, and the RTIC Ultralight 52 managed 6.3 days while weighing 21.6 pounds empty.

The bigger split is between rotomolded premium coolers and cheap blow-molded ones, and it is narrower than the prices suggest. The $55 Coleman Classic Series 52 lasted 4.4 days, almost the 4.5 days of the $325 Yeti Tundra 45. What the extra money buys is mostly toughness, better latches and lids that seal, so the cheap coolers suit weekend trips and the premium ones suit years of rough use or a week away from ice.

Our picks

  • Longest ice retention: Yeti Roadie 48. Drinks stayed cold 7.5 days, the longest of all 19, and it rolls on wheels at 26.6 pounds empty.
  • Most cold days for the money: Xspec 60qt. 6.7 cold drink days, second only to the Roadie 48, at a $230 list price for a 59.2 quart rotomolded chest.
  • Lightest long-haul chest: RTIC Ultralight 52. 6.3 cold drink days at 21.6 pounds empty, lighter than every rotomolded chest here.
  • Best budget cooler for weekends: Coleman Classic Series 65 Wheeled. $85 for 62.3 quarts and 96 cans on wheels, and drinks stayed cold 5.1 days.
  • Best soft cooler for insulation: Yeti Hopper M20 Backpack. 4.0 cold drink days, the best of the four soft coolers, in a backpack that weighs 5.2 pounds.

Rotomolded or blow-molded: what the extra money buys

Rotomolded coolers like the Yeti Tundra 45, RTIC 65, Engel 65 and ROVR RollR 60 cost $230 to $400 here, while the blow-molded Coleman Classic Series 52, Coleman Xtreme 50 with Wheels and Coleman Classic Series 65 Wheeled list at $55 to $85. In cold drink days the gap is small: the Coleman Classic Series 65 Wheeled held 5.1 days, more than the Tundra 45 at 4.5 and the Engel 65 at 5.0.

Where the cheap coolers fall short is build. Reviewers reported leaky lids on the Coleman Classic Series 52, the Igloo Polar 120 and the Igloo Marine Ultra 70, and the Coleman Xtreme 50 with Wheels has no lid gasket at all. If the cooler will ride in a truck bed or a boat for years, that is the case for paying more.

Why a 45-quart cooler may hold 35 quarts

The number in a cooler's name is not always its volume. The Yeti Tundra 45 measured 35.0 quarts and 54 cans, the Yeti Tundra 65 measured 56.0 quarts, and the Engel 65 measured 48.0 quarts. The Coleman Xtreme 50 with Wheels, by contrast, measured the full 52.0 quarts it is named for. Compare the Capacity and Can Capacity columns rather than model names when sizing for a group.

Wheels, weight and who does the carrying

Empty weight decides whether one person can load a cooler alone. The ROVR RollR 60 weighs 36.6 pounds and the RTIC 65 weighs 35.4 pounds before any ice goes in, while the Coleman Classic Series 65 Wheeled weighs 13.8 pounds and the Igloo Polar 120 just 18.0 pounds for 186 cans. Wheels help on pavement; the RollR 60's air-filled tires are the ones built for gravel and rough trails.

Soft coolers are for a day or two

The four soft coolers held drinks cold for 2.3 to 4.0 days, while every hard cooler here lasted at least 3.8 days and most lasted 4.4 or more. In exchange they weigh 3.6 to 5.2 pounds. The Engel HD30 carries the most at 63 cans, the IceMule Pro 33 is a roll-top dry bag that floats for kayak days, and the Arctic Zone Titan Deep Freeze 30 is the cheapest at $70.

The options in detail

Yeti Tundra 45

Yeti's classic mid-size chest cooler, with a dry basket, tie-down loops, rubber feet and IGBC bear-resistance certification. Reviewers like how simply it is built and how well it travels on a road trip. The catch is the name: measured, it holds just under 35 quarts, so it is smaller than the 45 suggests and heavy for its size.

Yeti Tundra 65

The bigger Tundra, and the one reviewers call close to the last chest cooler you will need: very durable, with comfortable handles and an included dry bin. Reviewers rated its insulation below par for longer trips, and it measured smaller than its name. The plug has no leash and the price is high.

Yeti Roadie 48

A tall wheeled cooler that rolls and stacks like carry-on luggage and stands a two-liter bottle upright. It kept drinks cold longer than any other cooler in OutdoorGearLab's test, which is why it is their overall pick. It is expensive, the lock needs installing, and the most useful add-ons are sold separately.

Yeti Roadie 60

The larger Roadie, pulled by an extending handle and two sturdy wheels, with fixed side handles for lifting it into a car. It fits nearly 100 cans or upright wine bottles and holds cold well. Reviewers flag the price and a lid that is not leakproof.

RTIC Ultralight 52

An injection-molded chest cooler that insulated as well as most rotomolded coolers in testing while weighing much less, and the reviewers' pick for insulation for the money. The thick lid doubles as a table or cutting board. Downsides: flimsy latches and hinges, a lid that can leak, and the basket and dividers are now sold separately.

RTIC 65

A big rotomolded chest with two drains, comfortable grips and a freezer-style gasket, built to take abuse. It is a lot of cooler for one person to carry, and its stretchy latches and unleashed plug drew complaints. Its street price swings a lot, so timing the purchase matters.

RTIC Ultra-Light 22

A small, strap-carried hard cooler for one person or a day trip, like an upgraded lunchbox, with a freezer-grade gasket and a silicone pocket in the lid. It keeps things cold for a little over three days. Reviewers think it is pricey for how little it holds.

Engel 65

A rotomolded chest from one of the original high-performance cooler makers, often priced below the big names. Reviewers found it good rather than great at everything, with tough construction and easy latches, and light for a rotomolded cooler its size. It measured smaller than advertised, and the handles are uncomfortable.

Xspec 60qt

A lesser-known rotomolded chest with three inches of insulation, bottle openers, anti-skid feet and removable handles, and one of the cheaper full-size rotomolded coolers reviewers tested. It kept ice longer than most of the field. It has no internal basket and is not IGBC bear-rated.

ROVR RollR 60

A rotomolded roller with big air-filled tires for sand, gravel and rough trails, plus anchor points for strapping gear on top. It holds ice for most of a week. It is one of the heaviest coolers tested, the carry handles are uncomfortable, and the tires arrive flat, so bring a pump.

Igloo Polar 120

A huge, inexpensive chest that holds 186 cans and weighs very little for its size, made for parties, family gatherings and team events. Reviewers found the build flimsy and the lid leaky when the cooler tips, so it suits occasional big days more than years of hard use.

Igloo Marine Ultra 70

A large, affordable marine chest with stainless hardware, a fish ruler on the lid and upgrades meant to make it last longer than older Igloos. It insulated adequately in testing. The lid leaks, it cannot be locked, and reviewers still had doubts about its long-term durability.

Coleman Classic Series 52

A cheap, light chest cooler with four cup holders in the lid, fine for day trips and the odd weekend. Its insulation fades after a few days, the lid leaks, and reviewers doubt it will last, so it suits someone who uses a cooler a couple of times a year.

Coleman Xtreme 50 with Wheels

A light, low-cost wheeled cooler that rolls better than its price suggests, for a lake day or a short weekend. It has no lid gasket and no molded drainage channels, and its insulation is middling, so plan trips around how long it holds ice.

Coleman Classic Series 65 Wheeled

OutdoorGearLab's everyday pick: a big wheeled cooler that is light for its size and kept drinks cold about five days in testing, enough for a weekend campout. The lid will not stay propped open, the small side handles feel spongy under load, and the drain plug sits where it is easy to bump.

Engel HD30

A large, tough tote-style soft cooler with an airtight zipper, a comfortable shoulder strap and a removable bottle opener. Reviewers rank it the best soft cooler they have tested for insulation and durability. It is big for a soft cooler, and the outside pocket is not waterproof.

Yeti Hopper M20 Backpack

A roll-top backpack cooler with a DryHide shell, and the best-insulated, most durable soft cooler in OutdoorGearLab's test. It carries comfortably on the back for a hike or a beach walk. It is expensive, the buckles are hard to clasp, it has no pockets, and it does not fold down for storage.

Arctic Zone Titan Deep Freeze 30

A zipperless flip-top soft cooler with plenty of outside pockets and a removable shelf that keeps dry food off the ice. It insulates better than most soft coolers at a price reviewers call hard to beat. It is not watertight and is less durable than the premium bags.

IceMule Pro 33

A roll-top dry-bag cooler with backpack straps that is waterproof and floats, made for kayaks, paddleboards and river days. It holds plenty of cans and wine bottles. Digging to the bottom is awkward, it has no carry handles, and the straps rub on bare skin.

How we researched this

Every value in this table comes from OutdoorGearLab's published review page for that cooler, which reports a standardized ice test (days until drinks warmed above 50°F), measured empty weight, measured interior volume and a can count, plus the list price at the time of review. Each cell is recorded with the sentence or spec line it came from. Soft coolers were measured in liters and are converted to quarts, and they were tested in a separate round from the hard coolers, so compare soft against soft for ice retention.

The set is the coolers in those two tests that are still widely sold. The RTIC 20, Igloo BMX 25 and Coleman Snap 'N Go 45 were left out, as were well-known coolers that test did not cover, such as Pelican, Canyon, Grizzly and Bison. A blank Construction cell means the review named a material rather than how the body was made. List prices move often, especially for RTIC and Engel, so check the current price before buying.

Related comparisons