Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati
Cincinnati ice cream shops compared on style, rating and year opened, from Graeter's and Aglamesis to Putz's, Zip Dip and Dojo Gelato. Read our take
At a glance
| Option | Address | Neighborhood | Style | Rating | Number of ratings | Year opened |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 511 Walnut Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202source | Downtownsource | Hand-scooped ice creamsource | 4.2source | 256source | 1870source | |
| 3046 Madison Road, Cincinnati, OH 45209source | Oakleysource | Hand-scooped ice creamsource | 4.6source | 343source | 1908source | |
| 725 Race Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202source | Downtownsource | Hand-scooped ice creamsource | 4.7source | 285source | 2012source | |
| 137 West Elder Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202source | Findlay Marketsource | Gelatosource | 4.5source | 137source | 2009source | |
| 1733 Elm Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202source | Findlay Marketsource | Gelatosource | 4.8source | 77source | ||
| 2755 Park Avenue, Norwood, OH 45212source | Norwoodsource | Hand-scooped ice creamsource | 4.5source | 117source | ||
| 10235 Summit Parkway, Blue Ash, OH 45242source | Blue Ashsource | Hand-scooped ice creamsource | 4.7source | 147source | 2022source | |
| 2673 Putz Place, Cincinnati, OH 45211source | East Westwoodsource | Soft servesource | 4.8source | 330source | 1938source | |
| 4050 Drew Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45248source | Dentsource | Soft servesource | 4.8source | 209source | 1950source | |
| 2069 Beechmont Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45230source | Mt. Washingtonsource | Soft servesource | 4.6source | 153source | ||
| 4490 Forest Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45212source | Norwoodsource | Soft servesource | 4.7source | 178source | ||
| 2810 Blue Rock Road, Cincinnati, OH 45239source | White Oaksource | Soft servesource | 4.5source | 185source | 1968source | |
| 508 Wyoming Avenue, Wyoming, OH 45215source | Wyomingsource | Soft serve and hand-dippedsource | 4.8source | 105source | 2019source | |
| 6918 Plainfield Road, Cincinnati, OH 45236source | Silvertonsource | Soft servesource | 4.9source | 165source | 2016source |
Our take
For the classic answer, Graeter's has been making ice cream in small French pots since 1870, and the Fountain Square shop downtown is the easiest place to try it. If you go by customer ratings instead, the soft serve stands come out on top: The Dipper in Silverton rates 4.9 out of 5, and Putz's Creamy Whip, which opened in 1938, holds 4.8 across 330 ratings.
The real split in this table is scooped ice cream versus soft serve. Creamy whips, Cincinnati's name for a walk-up soft serve stand, make up nearly half of this list, and most of them close for the cold months. The scoop shops and the two gelato makers at Findlay Market, Dojo Gelato and uGOgelato, are where you go for rotating flavors made in house.
Our picks
- The Cincinnati classic: Graeter's Ice Cream (Fountain Square). Made in French pots since 1870, the oldest maker on this list, right on Fountain Square.
- Best old-school creamy whip: Putz's Creamy Whip. Open since 1938 and rated 4.8 out of 5 across 330 ratings, the most of any creamy whip here.
- Best scoop shop downtown: Hello Honey (Race Street). Rated 4.7 out of 5 from 285 ratings, with every flavor and waffle cone made on site since 2012.
- Best gelato: uGOgelato. Rated 4.8 out of 5, with plant-based gelato made alongside the traditional kind near Findlay Market.
- Best old-fashioned parlor: Aglamesis Bro's (Oakley Square). A family ice cream and chocolate maker since 1908, rated 4.6 out of 5 across 343 ratings.
Scooped ice cream or a creamy whip
Five shops here scoop ice cream they make themselves: Graeter's, Aglamesis Bro's, Hello Honey, Jeni's in Norwood and Gold Spoon Creamery in Blue Ash. They rotate flavors through the year, and Graeter's and Jeni's sit at the higher end on price. Cowboy Cones in Wyoming is the one shop that does both, hand-dipping Chocolate Shoppe ice cream from Wisconsin beside its own soft serve flavors.
The creamy whips are a different outing: a window, a short menu of vanilla, chocolate and twist often with a Dole flavor, and picnic tables. Putz's, Zip Dip and Gold Top Dairy Bar have been serving since 1938, 1950 and 1968, and Norwood Delite has fed its neighborhood for generations. The Dipper in Silverton, opened in 2016, stretches the same format to blueberry, bubble gum and three kinds of Dole Whip.
Check the season and bring cash
Most of the creamy whips on this list close for winter and reopen in spring, so in the cold months a scoop shop is the safer bet. Putz's and Norwood Delite take cash only, while The Dipper takes cards. The two Findlay Market gelato shops keep short market hours, and Dojo Gelato is closed on Mondays.
Gelato at Findlay Market
Dojo Gelato has scooped inside Findlay Market since 2009 and always keeps at least three dairy-free sorbetti in its case. uGOgelato, a short walk away on Elm Street, is run by a second-generation Sicilian gelato maker and gives its plant-based flavors equal space. Both rate well, at 4.5 and 4.8 out of 5, so trying one of each on a market morning is an easy plan.
The options in detail
Graeter's Ice Cream (Fountain Square)
The name most Cincinnatians mean when they say local ice cream, made since 1870 in small French pots, which is where the dense texture and the big, irregular chocolate chunks come from. Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip is the flavor people order first. The Fountain Square shop is the downtown flagship and also sells pastries, but the room is small and works better for a cone to carry out onto the square than for sitting down.
Aglamesis Bro's (Oakley Square)
A family ice cream and chocolate maker that has used the same recipes since 1908, and its Oakley Square parlor is the nearest thing in the city to a preserved old-time soda fountain, with vintage chairs and a historic storefront. Regulars go for Dutch Chocolate, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip and the hot fudge sundaes, and the chocolate counter makes it an easy stop for a gift. The room is small, so a big group will mostly be standing. The family also runs parlors in Montgomery and Hamilton.
Hello Honey (Race Street)
A downtown shop that makes its ice cream, desserts and waffle cones on site, and reviewers say you can smell the cones from the sidewalk. The flavor board rotates through things like banana honeycomb, honey lavender and brown butter caramel, with two sorbets and a vegan cookies and cream for anyone avoiding dairy. Staff hand out samples freely, and the cakes, especially the Boston cream, have their own fans. There are two more shops, on Madison Road and Ridge Avenue, with shorter weekday hours.
Dojo Gelato (Findlay Market)
The original Dojo stand inside Findlay Market, with gelato and sorbetto made by hand in five-gallon batches at the company's Northside kitchen. Flavors rotate constantly, from Tahitian vanilla to stranger ones, and there are always at least three dairy-free sorbetti in the case. The espresso is taken as seriously as the gelato, so some regulars treat it as a breakfast stop. It keeps market hours: closed Mondays and shut by late afternoon on Sundays.
uGOgelato
A small gelato shop on Elm Street a few steps from Findlay Market, run by a second-generation Sicilian gelato maker who has placed in international gelato competitions. Plant-based flavors get equal billing with the traditional ones, and reviewers single out the vegan flavors and the pistachio. Expect to be offered tastes before you choose. Seating is a few stools inside and out, prices run a little higher than a scoop shop, and hours are short and change through the year, so check before going.
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams (Norwood)
The Cincinnati shop of the Ohio ice cream company, in the Factory 52 development on Park Avenue in Norwood, with a patio and easy parking. Flavors lean inventive (gooey butter cake, salted black licorice, popcorn brittle) and every scoop comes with a piece of waffle cookie. There is a full non-dairy line, and staff are generous with samples. Reviewers agree it is one of the pricier scoops in town, and it stays open until 11pm every night.
Gold Spoon Creamery
A husband-and-wife shop at Summit Park in Blue Ash that started with a wedding-present ice cream maker and now makes small batches in house, served with a gold-colored spoon. Reviewers praise the cookie dough, pistachio and chocolate chocolate chip, and there are vegan and gluten-free options. Waffle cones are made on site, there is seating inside and out, and the shop also pours coffee and takes orders for custom cakes and pies.
Putz's Creamy Whip
A family creamy whip that began in 1938 in a pair of old streetcars and now runs from a walk-up stand below Mt. Airy Forest, still in the same family. The order is a twist cone, often dipped in chocolate, though root beer floats, red cows and footlong chili dogs have their own following. Picnic tables and an open lawn make it easy with kids. It is cash only, and like most creamy whips it closes for the cold months.
Zip Dip
The West Side creamy whip with the neon lightning bolt on the roof, serving soft serve from a window since 1950. The orange and vanilla twist is the local order, and the pineapple sherbet, malts and footlong cheese coneys come up in nearly every review. There is no indoor seating, but picnic tables and bench swings fill the lot and the line moves fast. Prices are low, and it closes for the winter.
Mt. Washington Creamy Whip & Bakery
A family-run creamy whip on Beechmont Avenue, grown out of the owner's grandfather's bakery, with walls covered in old Cincinnati memorabilia and a few tables outside. Soft serve comes in vanilla, chocolate and swirl with weekly specials and a long toppings list, and this is the shop that brought edible cookie dough to the family's other parlors. Reviewers mention lines out the door on hot nights but quick service. It is seasonal, and regulars wish it stayed open year round.
Norwood Delite Creamy Whip
A no-frills Norwood stand that has been serving the neighborhood for generations, best known for blueberry soft serve, the flavor many locals remember from Kings Island. The menu runs to Dole Whip, sundaes and waffle cone sundaes, plus footlongs and burgers. Seating is picnic tables outside. Bring cash, since it does not take cards, and expect it to be closed in the cold months.
Gold Top Dairy Bar
A walk-up dairy bar under a bright yellow roof on Blue Rock Road, open since 1968. The soft serve comes in a few classic flavors plus blue raspberry and pineapple Dole, and there are ice cream cakes and pints to take home. A covered seating area keeps the wind off, and there is a drive-thru, though reviewers say it can be slow. It is a summer place, closed for the off-season.
Cowboy Cones
A cow-print ice cream stop on Wyoming Avenue that serves both kinds: hand-dipped scoops of Chocolate Shoppe ice cream, a super-premium brand made in Madison, Wisconsin, and a rotating line of soft serve flavors. Unlike most shops here, the scooped ice cream is bought in rather than made on site, which is the draw for fans of that brand. Order at the walk-up window or go inside. The waffle cones are homemade.
The Dipper
A seasonal soft serve stand on Plainfield Road in Silverton, named for the neighborhood's old Big Dipper and run as a community spot through the spring and summer. Flavors go beyond chocolate and vanilla to blueberry, blue, bubble gum and three kinds of Dole Whip, with shakes, slushees, coneys and walking tacos. Reviewers point to low prices and quick lines, and it takes cards, which not every creamy whip does. It sits near a brewery, so it works as a dessert stop after dinner.
How we researched this
We started from local guides, including CityBeat's reader poll and its creamy whip roundups, and then read each shop's own website and its Restaurantji listing. Every rating and rating count comes from Restaurantji so the numbers compare, and the address, style and opening year each carry the sentence they came from. A blank Year opened means no page we read stated a year.
We kept the list to shops in Ohio. Shops across the river in Northern Kentucky, such as Schneider's Sweet Shop and Golden Gelato, are left out, as are chains like United Dairy Farmers. Pendleton Parlor, Simply Rolled Ice Cream and General Custer's are not included because we could not confirm they are still operating as listed. Hours change with the season, so check before you go.













