Best Pizza in Boulder, CO

Fifteen Boulder pizzerias compared on rating, style and kind of spot, from Pizza Colore's New York slices to Pizzeria Alberico's Napoletana pies. Read our take

At a glance

OptionAddressRatingNumber of RatingsPizza StyleKind of SpotAmenities
1730 Pearl Street, Boulder, CO 80302source4.2source536sourceNeapolitansourceSit-down restaurantsourcePrivate dining room, Happy hour food, Great cocktailssource
3601 Arapahoe Avenue, Boulder, CO 80303source4.4source396sourceWood-firedsourceSit-down restaurantsourceOutdoor seating, Vegetarian options, Great cocktailssource
1644 Walnut Street, Boulder, CO 80302source4.4source213sourceModern AmericansourceSit-down restaurantsourceOutdoor seating, Fireplacesource
1336 Pearl Street, Boulder, CO 80302source4.7source407sourceNew YorksourceSlice shopsourceOutdoor seating, Vegan optionssource
1805 29th St, Boulder, CO 80301source4.2source59sourceMultiple stylessourceSlice shopsourceOutdoor seatingsource
2319 Arapahoe Avenue, Boulder, CO 80302source4.4source345sourcePub & tap housesourceVegetarian options, Private dining room, Happy hour foodsource
2675 13th Street, Boulder, CO 80304source4.4source404sourceNew YorksourceSlice shopsourceOutdoor seating, Vegan optionssource
659 30th Street, Boulder, CO 80303source4.2source319sourceThin crustsourceSlice shopsourceVegetarian options, High chairssource
1647 Arapahoe Avenue, Boulder, CO 80302source4.2source250sourceNew YorksourceSlice shopsourceDogs allowedsource
1401 Pearl St, Boulder, CO 80302source4.4source94sourceNew YorksourceFood-hall countersourceOutdoor seating, Vegetarian options, High chairssource
4670 Broadway, Boulder, CO 80304source4.4source206sourceNeapolitansourceSit-down restaurantsourceOutdoor seating, Vegan optionssource
2761 Iris Avenue, Boulder, CO 80304source4.1source186sourceNew YorksourceCarryout & deliverysourceOutdoor seating, Vegan optionssource
1165 13th Street, Boulder, CO 80302source4.5source735sourceColorado-stylesourceSit-down restaurantsourceHappy hour food, Great cocktailssource
2609 Pearl Street, Boulder, CO 80302source4.7source87sourceDetroitsourceCarryout & deliverysource
2900 Valmont Road, Boulder, CO 80301source4.6source253sourceNeapolitansourcePub & tap housesourceOutdoor seating, Great cocktailssource

Our take

For a slice, Pizza Colore on the Pearl Street Mall ties Jet's Pizza for the top score here, 4.7 out of 5, and holds it across 407 Restaurantji ratings to Jet's 87, for New York-style pizza sold by the slice. For a sit-down pizza dinner, The Sink has more ratings than anywhere else on this list, 735 at 4.5, while Basta and Barchetta both hold 4.4 with a full dining room around the oven. Just behind the leaders, Fringe, A Well-Tapped Eatery on Valmont Road holds 4.6 across 253 ratings for Neapolitan-style pies and a self-pour tap wall. Boulder Weekly readers, for their part, voted Cosmo's Pizza the best pizza restaurant and the best slice in 2025, with Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage second in both.

The real split is between slice counters and restaurants. Five places here sell slices over a counter, from Brooklyn Pizza near the Hill to Slice House by Tony Gemignani at Twenty Ninth Street, while Pizzeria Alberico, Basta, Barchetta, Proto's Pizza and The Sink are places to sit down with a drink. Style splits the set too: Napoletana pies at Pizzeria Alberico, Proto's and Fringe, a thick Colorado crust at The Sink, and Detroit squares at Jet's Pizza.

Our picks

  • Best slice: Pizza Colore. New York-style slices on the Pearl Street Mall, rated 4.7 across 407 ratings.
  • Best Neapolitan pie: Pizzeria Alberico. Classic Napoletana pizza with a full cocktail bar, rated 4.2 across 536 ratings.
  • Best for a dinner out: Basta. Wood-fired pizza in a sit-down room, rated 4.4 across 396 ratings.
  • Most styles in one shop: Slice House by Tony Gemignani. Four styles, from New York slices to Detroit squares, at Twenty Ninth Street.
  • Best with a beer: Backcountry Pizza & Tap House. A tap house with more than 60 beers on draft, rated 4.4 across 345 ratings.

Slice counter or sit-down pizza dinner

Pizza Colore, Brooklyn Pizza, Cosmo's Pizza, Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage and Slice House by Tony Gemignani all sell pizza by the slice, which makes them the quick, cheap choice for one person or a mixed order. Pizzeria Alberico, Basta, Barchetta, Proto's Pizza and The Sink are full restaurants, and Pizzeria Alberico and Backcountry Pizza & Tap House both list a private dining room for a group.

Check the hours before a sit-down plan. Basta serves dinner only, 5 to 9 every night, and Pizzeria Alberico serves lunch only Friday through Sunday.

Neapolitan, New York or Colorado-style crust

New York-style is the most common style here: Pizza Colore, Brooklyn Pizza, Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage, Abo's Pizza and New Yorkese all describe their pies that way, and New Yorkese aims for a Naples-like chew on its 72-hour dough. Pizzeria Alberico and Proto's Pizza make Napoletana pies, Fringe, A Well-Tapped Eatery puts the emphasis on Neapolitan-style pizza, and Basta cooks in a wood-fired oven.

For something different, The Sink's Ugly Crust is a thick Colorado-style crust that welcomes honey, Jet's Pizza builds its menu around Detroit-style squares, and Slice House by Tony Gemignani bakes New York, Sicilian, Grandma and Detroit pies side by side.

Delivery and pickup in Boulder

Abo's Pizza in North Boulder sends every delivery through third-party apps, so calling it in for pickup avoids the extra fees, and Jet's Pizza is set up mainly for delivery and takeout. Pizza Colore delivers only to a limited area, north of Arapahoe in the evening, and New Yorkese has no phone line at all, so order there in person or online. Boulder Weekly readers voted Cosmo's Pizza the best food delivery in town in 2025.

Late nights and closed days

Cosmo's Pizza at Baseline and 30th stays open until 2 on Friday and Saturday nights, and Brooklyn Pizza runs until midnight on those nights but is closed on Sundays. Backcountry Pizza & Tap House is closed on Mondays, and Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage closes at 8 every night.

The options in detail

Pizzeria Alberico

The Pearl Street pizzeria from the Frasca Food and Wine family, the room that used to be Pizzeria Locale, now billed as classic Napoletana pizza alongside Southern Italian plates from fritti to gelato. A full bar leans on Italian spirits and Southern Italian wine, with aperitivo every afternoon from 4 to 6. Reviewers praise the fluffy crust and the patio; lunch runs only Friday to Sunday, and a 2.5% health and wellness fee is added to every check.

Basta

An east Boulder restaurant opened in 2010 around a single wood-fired oven, serving dinner only, seven nights a week. The menu is short and changes often; reviewers single out the clam pizza, the Daisy pizza, the burrata and the wood-smoked ice cream. It is a dinner-out place rather than a pizza joint, and one reviewer flags a 20% gratuity added to the bill.

Barchetta

A Walnut Street pizzeria that made Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives in 2024, where Guy Fieri tried the cheeseburger pizza and the green-chile Verde Verde. Every pie is 14 inches on a crust of locally milled grain, soft at the edge and crisp underneath. A self-serve tap wall of beer and wine, a patio and a private dining room make it a group spot, though reviewers call it a bit pricey.

Pizza Colore

A locally owned quick-service shop on the Pearl Street Mall that has sold New York-style pizza for more than 20 years, with dough hand-stretched daily. You can get slices, whole pies, calzones and Italian sandwiches, and it stays open until 10 every night. Delivery covers only a limited area, north of Arapahoe in the evening.

Slice House by Tony Gemignani

World pizza champion Tony Gemignani's fast-casual shop in the Twenty Ninth Street district, his second in Colorado after Loveland. It bakes four styles side by side: big foldable New York slices, tall Sicilian squares, Grandma pies and Detroit-style, with slices kept in a case and reheated to order. It is the newest place here, so its reviews are still few.

Backcountry Pizza & Tap House

A lively sports bar on Arapahoe with more than 60 beers on draft and over 300 bottles, plus an arcade room with pool tables and pinball and Geeks Who Drink trivia on Wednesdays. It pitches its burgers as hard as its pizza, so this is the pick when the beer list matters as much as the pie. Closed Mondays.

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage

A family-owned shop on 13th Street north of downtown, featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. The naturally leavened dough ferments for three days before an electric deck oven, and the menu runs from 16- and 20-inch New York pies to a Sicilian and a sesame Grandma pie named for the owner's mother. Reviewers rave about the Sicilian meatball slice and the meatball grinder; it closes at 8 every night.

Cosmo's Pizza (Baseline & 30th)

Boulder Weekly readers voted Cosmo's the best pizza restaurant, best slice and best food delivery in town in 2025. This Baseline and 30th shop is the late-night one, open until 2 on weekend nights, selling giant slices that regulars top with spicy ranch and a two-slices-and-a-Coke lunch deal. A gluten-free crust is offered on 16-inch specialty pies, though the shop warns the kitchen is not gluten-free.

Brooklyn Pizza

A New York-style counter on Arapahoe near the Hill selling pizza by the slice and by the pie, with specialties like sausage and broccoli rabe or margherita with arugula. Reviewers like the soft-but-crisp crust and the classic pizza-joint feel. It is open until midnight on Friday and Saturday but closed on Sundays.

New Yorkese

A pizza stall on the rooftop of Avanti Food & Beverage on Pearl Street, with views of the Flatirons. Its dough blends freshly milled organic spelt, rye and bread flour and matures for 72 hours, aiming for a Naples-like chew with crisp New York edges. Weekday lunch brings a 14-inch cheese pie and a Coke for $12; there is no phone line, so order in person or online.

Proto's Pizza (North Boulder)

The north Broadway branch of a local chain started by Pam Proto, who moved from Boston and missed the thin, bubbly, charred pizza of the East Coast. The pies are Neapolitan-leaning, made in an open kitchen you can watch, and the gluten-free crust is a big reason people come. There are other Proto's in Gunbarrel, Longmont, Lafayette, Broomfield and Denver.

Abo's Pizza (North Boulder)

Abo's has been making pizza in Boulder since 1977; founder Steve Abo learned the trade in New York pizzerias, and the dough is hand-tossed fresh daily. This North Boulder shop sits in the Willow Springs Shopping Center on Iris and is set up for pick-up, with all delivery going through third-party apps. Reviewers describe a crust somewhere between New York and Colorado styles.

The Sink

A Boulder institution on the Hill since 1923, with graffiti-covered walls and ceilings and a long list of famous visitors, including a president who ordered a pizza to go. It is known first for burgers, but its Ugly Crust pizza, a thick Colorado-style crust that welcomes a drizzle of honey, is a Tuesday tradition. Pizzas come in 10, 13 and 18-inch sizes.

Jet's Pizza (Pearl Street)

A franchise of the family-owned Jet's chain at 26th and Pearl, built around Detroit-style square pizza, though it also makes round, thin and New York-style pies. Reviewers who want deep-dish or Detroit corners call it their go-to in Boulder and like the wings. It is set up mainly for delivery and takeout orders.

Fringe, A Well-Tapped Eatery

A Valmont Road eatery built around Neapolitan-style pizza on a sourdough dough the owners say took a year to develop, with Southern Italian small plates and pastas for the table. The other draw is Boulder's first self-pour tap wall, 16 beers and wines you pour yourself, and Best of Boulder County readers named it Best New Restaurant in 2021. Reviewers single out the funghi pizza and the crispy Brussels sprouts. It does not take reservations, and it sits northeast of downtown rather than on Pearl Street.

How we researched this

We read each pizzeria's own website and menu for its style and what kind of place it is, its Restaurantji listing for the address, the customer rating and how many ratings it rests on, and the amenity list, and local coverage (Boulder Weekly's 2025 Best of Boulder, a DiningOut feature on Slice House, the Denver Post on Barchetta) where a shop's own site said little. Each value was recorded with the sentence it came from, and every rating comes from Restaurantji so the column compares like with like.

The set covers Boulder's well-reviewed independent pizzerias plus one location each of the local chains Cosmo's, Abo's and Proto's, and Jet's for Detroit-style. We left out the national delivery chains (Domino's, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars), Nick-N-Willy's at 3.9, and Boss Lady Pizza on the Hill, which is listed as closed. A blank cell means no page we read stated it: Backcountry Pizza & Tap House never names its pizza style, and Jet's Pizza has no amenity list. Hours and delivery areas change, so confirm with the shop before you go.

Related comparisons