Best Restaurants in Indianapolis

25 Indianapolis favorites compared on cuisine, diner rating, meals served and signature dish, from St. Elmo Steak House and Vida to Shapiro's and Yats. Read our take

At a glance

OptionCuisineRatingRatingsMealsKnown forAddress
Steakhousesource4.4source1,524sourceDinnersourceShrimp cocktail with spicy signature sauce, classic steakssource127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225source
Italiansource4.6source629sourceDinnersourceTraditional Italian favorites like pasta, veal, and house-made saucessource1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220source
Burgers & bar foodsource4.5source676sourceLunch, DinnersourceHermanaki wings, pub food classics, and generous portionssource8617 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46250source
Delisource4.4source897sourceBreakfast, Lunch, DinnersourcePastrami, corned beef, matzo ball soup, and freshly baked dessertssource808 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225source
Modern Americansource4.5source564sourceLunch, DinnersourceLemon spaghetti, pickles and cheese, roasted cauliflower, pierogisource653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203source
Breakfast & brunchsource4.5source340sourceBreakfast, LunchsourceCinnamon toast, three-egg French-style omelettes, and the best ever chicken saladsource4901 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46205source
Thaisource4.7source337sourceDinnersourceTamarind peanut noodles (Guaytiew Pad Thai)source922 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Pizzasource4.4source512sourceLunch, DinnersourceQuattro Formaggio signature pizzasource329 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204source
Latin Americansource4.6source1,048sourceDinnersourceLatin American small plates, empanadas, and wood-fired entreessource720 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Burgers & bar foodsource4.7source439sourceLunchsourceCharbroiled smash burgers and onion ringssource234 N Belmont Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46222source
Italiansource4.5source966sourceLunch, DinnersourceClassic Southern Italian recipes such as lasagne bolognese and pistachio crusted salmonsource946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225source
Seafoodsource4.2source1,839sourceBrunch, Lunch, DinnersourceSeafood dishes, patio dining, and sunset viewssource4050 Dandy Trail, Indianapolis, IN 46254source
Cajunsource4.2source365sourceLunch, DinnersourceCrawfish étouffée, gumbo and the B&B, served on ricesource885 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204source
Steakhousesource4.3source1,425sourceLunch, DinnersourceSteaks, seafood, and classic American dishes inspired by St. Elmo favoritessource153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225source
Latin Americansource4.7source265sourceLunch, DinnersourceBrazilian-style entrees, tacos, and house specialties rooted in family recipessource6320 Ferguson St, Indianapolis, IN 46220source
Germansource4.3source872sourceLunch, DinnersourceJaegerschnitzel, bratwurst, and traditional German faresource401 E Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46204source
Delisource4.3source238sourceLunch, DinnersourceItalian beef sandwiches, wings, burgers, and indulgent pub faresource5410 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220source
Modern Americansource4.5source478sourceDinnersourceSeasonal shared plates, fried Brussels sprouts, duck breast, pumpkin gnocchisource402 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Pizzasource4.6source441sourceLunch, DinnersourceThick-crust Detroit-style pizzas, tavern-cut pies, and rotating specialty toppingssource19 Cruse St, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Pizzasource4.3source445sourceLunch, DinnersourcePizzas on house-fermented dough with seasonal toppingssource452 N Highland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Modern Americansource4.9source584sourceDinnersourceFour- or six-course tasting menussource601 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46202source
Breakfast & brunchsource4.8source197sourceBreakfast, Brunch, LunchsourceOmelets and eggs Benedictsource150 W Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204source
Burgers & bar foodsource4.6source348sourceDinnersourceScrumptious ramen dishes packed with flavor, wings, and dumplingssource128 S Audubon Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46219source
Seafoodsource4.5source406sourceBrunch, DinnersourcePremium steaks, fresh seafood and an expansive raw barsource110 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204source
Modern Americansource4.5source551sourceDinnersourceKing salmon, handmade tagliatelle and sticky toffee puddingsource8605 River Crossing Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46240source

Our take

For one standout dinner, Vida has the highest diner rating in this table, 4.9 out of 5 from 584 ratings, for four- or six-course tasting menus. For the meal most visitors are told to have, St. Elmo Steak House pairs its spicy shrimp cocktail with classic steaks and carries 1,524 ratings at 4.4.

The bigger split is when each place is open. Eight of these 25 serve dinner only, including St. Elmo, Livery, Tinker Street, Vida and Late Harvest Kitchen, while Cafe Patachou and Lincoln Square Pancake House are breakfast-and-lunch rooms and The Workingman's Friend serves lunch alone. Ratings are tightly bunched between 4.2 and 4.9, so cuisine and timing will narrow this list faster than the stars will.

Our picks

  • Special-occasion dinner: Vida. The top diner rating here, 4.9 from 584 ratings, for four- or six-course tasting menus.
  • Classic Indianapolis steak night: St. Elmo Steak House. The signature shrimp cocktail and traditional steak cuts, rated 4.4 across 1,524 ratings.
  • Breakfast downtown: Lincoln Square Pancake House (Market Street). Rated 4.8 and open for breakfast, brunch and lunch, with omelets and eggs Benedict the draw.
  • Cheap lunch: The Workingman's Friend. Charbroiled smash burgers and onion rings at a lunch-only bar rated 4.7.
  • Dinner with a view: Rick's Cafe Boatyard. Seafood and sunset views on the reservoir, with Sunday brunch and the most ratings here, 1,839.

Steakhouse splurge or tasting menu

St. Elmo Steak House and Harry & Izzy's share a block of South Illinois Street. St. Elmo serves dinner only, while Harry & Izzy's opens for lunch and dinner with steaks, seafood and dishes inspired by St. Elmo favorites, rated 4.3 against St. Elmo's 4.4. Commission Row, beside Gainbridge Fieldhouse, adds a big raw bar to its steaks and seafood, is rated 4.5, and serves Sunday brunch as well as dinner.

If the occasion matters more than the steak, Vida, Tinker Street and Late Harvest Kitchen are the alternatives. Vida is a set tasting menu with the highest rating in the table, Tinker Street, rated 4.5, runs a seasonal menu of shared plates such as fried Brussels sprouts and duck breast, and Late Harvest Kitchen, also 4.5, is a farm-to-table room on the north side known for king salmon and handmade tagliatelle. All three are dinner only, so book ahead.

Check the hours before you go

Meal times rule out more options here than anything else. Cafe Patachou and Lincoln Square Pancake House close in the afternoon, The Workingman's Friend serves lunch only and only a few hours of it, and BODHI, Livery, Mama Carolla's and Strange Bird open in the evening. Rick's Cafe Boatyard is the only full-service room here that adds a Sunday brunch to lunch and dinner, and Shapiro's, the cafeteria-style deli, stays open into the evening every day.

Several are closed one or more days a week: Vida opens Tuesday to Saturday, Yats on Mass Ave and Late Harvest Kitchen close Sundays, and Strange Bird and Futuro close Mondays. Confirm the day you want on the restaurant's own site.

Detroit-style, wood-fired or classic pizza

Three pizzerias made the list, and they are different styles. Futuro, rated 4.6, makes thick-crust Detroit-style and tavern-cut pies; King Dough, rated 4.3, bakes pizzas on house-fermented dough with seasonal toppings; and Bazbeaux, rated 4.4 and serving since 1986, is known for its Quattro Formaggio signature pie.

The options in detail

St. Elmo Steak House

Indianapolis's best-known classic steakhouse, a downtown dining room of wood paneling and brick on South Illinois Street. Its shrimp cocktail with a spicy signature cocktail sauce is the dish people come for, alongside prime rib and big rib eyes. Reviewers praise the service and the history but warn the room gets loud, and Restaurantji puts it in its most expensive $$$$ band, with Vida and Commission Row.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

A red-sauce Italian dinner house in a former monastery in Broad Ripple, with candlelit rooms and an ivy-covered patio. Diners single out the veal marsala, garlic cheese bread, Italian wedding soup and spumoni. It is dinner only and keeps short weekday hours, so plan ahead and expect a wait on busy nights.

Ale Emporium (Castleton)

A Castleton sports bar that earns its place on locals' lists with its Hermannaki wings, lightly breaded and famously spicy. Expect a big beer list, a large patio, generous pub plates and TVs everywhere, which makes it a game-day favorite. It is a casual neighborhood bar first, not a destination dinner.

Shapiro's Delicatessen

A cafeteria-style Jewish deli south of downtown that has been feeding Indianapolis for more than a century. People order pastrami, corned beef, brisket on rye and matzo ball soup, then add a slice of pie or cheesecake from the dessert case. You carry your own tray and the room is loud and busy, which is part of the charm.

Bluebeard

A Fletcher Place restaurant named after a Kurt Vonnegut novel, set in a 1924 warehouse on the Cultural Trail with a menu that changes often. Regulars mention house chips with French onion dip, crispy Brussels sprouts, ricotta gnocchi and the lemon spaghetti, plus a serious cocktail and mocktail list. It is the place many locals take out-of-town friends, and the patio is a summer draw.

Cafe Patachou (49th & Penn)

Martha Hoover's breakfast-and-lunch cafe at 49th and Pennsylvania in Meridian-Kessler, one of several Patachou locations known for their farm-to-table menu and community work. The cinnamon toast, French-style omelettes and chicken salad are the classics, with a long coffee menu and plenty of vegetarian choices. It closes at 3pm daily, and weekend mornings get crowded.

BODHI Craft Bar + Thai Bistro

A women-owned Thai restaurant and cocktail bar on Mass Ave cooking family recipes from three generations. Reviewers rave about the khao soi, laab and drunken noodles, the depth of flavor, and an inventive drinks list that includes good alcohol-free options. It is dinner only, closed Tuesdays, with a patio that suits a date night.

Bazbeaux Pizza (Mass Ave)

A local pizza institution since 1986, known for dozens of specialty pies on hand-tossed crusts and a creamy basil house dressing. The Quattro Formaggio and Colossus pizzas get the most praise, along with the antipasto. Reviewers note the room near the Mass Ave entrance can feel cramped and large orders occasionally go astray, but it is one of the cheapest sit-down meals here.

Livery

A Latin American restaurant in a historic building near Mass Ave, with a rooftop patio and a bar built around tequila, mezcal and rum. The empanadas, yuca fries and cauliflower appetizer are the standouts in reviews. Main plates draw more mixed comments than the small plates, so many diners make a meal of shared starters.

The Workingman's Friend

A cash-only, no-frills bar on the near west side that has won best-burger honors in Indiana from Food & Wine and Yelp for its charbroiled smash burgers. Onion rings and chili round out a short menu. It is open only for a few lunch hours Tuesday through Saturday, so check before you go.

Iozzo's Garden of Italy

A Southern Italian restaurant south of downtown that traces its name to 1930 and returned in 2009 in an exposed-brick room hung with family photos. Diners praise the piccata, handmade pappardelle with short rib ragu and the courtyard patio on warm nights. It suits a relaxed dinner before a game or show downtown.

Rick's Cafe Boatyard

A waterfront seafood and American restaurant on Eagle Creek Reservoir on the far northwest side, chosen more for the sunset view than the location. The menu runs from oysters, crab cakes and stuffed grouper to steak and a short-rib grilled cheese, with Sunday brunch. Reviewers note outdoor seating is limited to the bar area and holidays book up early.

Yats (Mass Ave)

A fast, colorful Cajun and Creole counter with a menu that rotates daily, served over rice with a hunk of bread. Ordering half and half, two dishes on one plate, is the local move, and drunken chicken and chorizo etouffee are favorites. It is one of the best-value meals in the city, though reviewers note it is not strictly traditional Cajun cooking, and this location is closed Sundays.

Harry & Izzy's (Downtown)

The more relaxed sibling of St. Elmo, a few doors down on the same block of South Illinois Street, serving steaks, seafood and the same famous shrimp cocktail. Reviewers mention the rib eye, onion soup and polished service, and it opens for lunch, which St. Elmo does not. It is still a splurge, priced one notch below its sister.

Fernando's Mexican & Brazilian Cuisine

A family restaurant in Broad Ripple that pairs Mexican plates with Brazilian dishes rarely found elsewhere in the city. Coxinha, pao de queijo, picanha and feijoada are the dishes reviewers single out, along with a mango caipirinha. Service is described as friendly but occasionally uneven, and there is a second location on Mass Ave.

The Rathskeller

A German restaurant and beer hall in the basement of the historic Athenaeum on Michigan Street, with a large seasonal biergarten. Schnitzel, bratwurst and a giant pretzel with hot mustard lead the menu, backed by a long German and European beer list. Reviewers love the building and the portions but say service can be slow and some sides are ordinary.

Fat Dan's Deli (Broad Ripple)

A Chicago-style deli and sports bar on College Avenue in Broad Ripple, known for Italian beef, smoked wings, Chicago dogs and loaded tots. Sauces are made in house and portions are big. It is loud and casual, with games on every screen, and there is a second location near Mass Ave.

Tinker Street

A tiny, polished restaurant on 16th Street just north of downtown, with a seasonal menu that leans vegetable-forward and handles gluten-free and dairy-free diners well. Fried Brussels sprouts, Korean fried mushrooms, scallop risotto and duck dishes come up again and again in reviews. Seating is limited, so it is a book-ahead dinner spot, with a year-round patio.

Futuro

A Holy Cross neighborhood pizzeria that began as a pandemic side project and opened its shop in 2021, specializing in Detroit-style and Chicago tavern-style pies. Dough, sauce and most toppings are made from scratch, and the bacon basil Detroit pie is a reviewer favorite. Seating is limited and it closes early most nights, so many people order to go.

King Dough

A wood-fired pizza spot near downtown's east side whose naturally leavened crusts and offbeat combinations, like the pungent Stinky Pete, have a cult following. Fried cauliflower and the Greco salad are popular starters, and the cocktails get good reviews. It opens at 5pm on weekdays, with lunch only on weekends.

Vida

The highest-rated room in this set, a Lockerbie fine-dining restaurant where chef Thomas Melvin, a James Beard semifinalist, serves four- and six-course tasting menus. Reviewers describe the service as personal and the experience as worth traveling for, and a vegetarian tasting is available. Restaurantji rates it $$$$, with St. Elmo and Commission Row the priciest here, and it opens only Tuesday to Saturday evenings.

Lincoln Square Pancake House (Market Street)

A family-owned diner chain's downtown location on Market Street, a short walk from the convention hotels. It serves the classics in generous portions: pancakes, eggs Benedict variations, corned beef hash and seasonal French toast. It is quick, inexpensive and busy on weekend mornings, and closes at 3pm.

Strange Bird

An Irvington tiki bar with a moody interior and a kitchen that punches above its bar billing, best known for its ramen bowls such as tantanmen and shoyu. Dumplings, grilled oysters and vegan teriyaki wings round out the menu, with plenty of vegan options. It opens at 4pm and is closed Mondays, and gluten-free diners should note the noodles are wheat.

Commission Row

A multi-level downtown restaurant on Bicentennial Unity Plaza beside Gainbridge Fieldhouse, built around premium steaks, fresh seafood and a large raw bar, with Mel's speakeasy under the same roof. Reviewers single out the oysters, the steaks and the cocktail list, and like the view of the ice rink outside the windows, though some find the raw bar pricey. It opens in the late afternoon for dinner and adds brunch on Sundays.

Late Harvest Kitchen

A farm-to-table restaurant on the north side, open since 2011, cooking American dishes from Hoosier ingredients on a menu that rotates with the seasons. King salmon, handmade tagliatelle and sticky toffee pudding are the dishes it is known for, served in a wood-paneled room with a fireplace and a covered patio. Reviewers praise attentive service and the changing menu. It serves dinner only and is closed Sundays, so book ahead.

How we researched this

Most of the set comes from Visit Indy's list of Indy's 25 Best Restaurants, which the city's tourism bureau built from a vote of residents and visitors. We kept 23 of them: the 1933 Lounge is a cocktail bar beside St. Elmo rather than a restaurant, and Goose the Market is a butcher and grocery with no diner-rating listing to compare. We added Commission Row and Late Harvest Kitchen from Indianapolis Monthly's 2026 Best Restaurants list, two critics' picks a local would expect to see. Where a restaurant has several locations we chose one, named in the title, and its address and rating belong to that location.

Cuisine, diner rating and number of ratings come from each location's Restaurantji page, which averages diner reviews. Meals served and the dishes each place is known for come from the Visit Indy list or the restaurant's own site, and Shapiro's meals from the hours on its own site, which run past the breakfast and lunch Visit Indy lists. Every value was recorded with the sentence it came from. There is no price column because the only per-restaurant price information available was a dollar-sign band, not an actual price. Hours and menus change, so check with the restaurant before you go.

Related comparisons