Sunday Brunch in Indianapolis

Nineteen Indianapolis Sunday brunch spots compared on brunch hours, days, reservations, food and ratings, from Lincoln Square Pancake House to Commission Row. Read our take

At a glance

OptionAddressSunday brunch hoursBrunch daysReservationsFoodRatingRatings
534 Virginia Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46203source10AM - 3PMsourceFive days a weeksourceCafe & bakerysource4.1source407source
225 West Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204source8AM - 3PMsourceCafe & bakerysource4.7source640source
320 South Alabama Street Ste A, Indianapolis, IN 46204source8AM - 8PMsourceTakes reservationssourceSouthernsource4.1source596source
323 North Delaware Street Ste B, Indianapolis, IN 46204source10AM - 3PMsourceSaturday and SundaysourceTakes reservationssourceBar & pubsource4.3source468source
342 Massachusetts Avenue Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46204source9AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceWalk-in onlysourceJuice barsource4.4source363source
1001 East 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220source8AM - 2PMsourceSix days a weeksourceWalk-in onlysourceBreakfastsource4.5source402source
150 West Market Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204source7AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceBreakfastsource4.8source197source
2732 Westlane Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268source8AM - 3PMsourceBreakfastsource4.8source166source
110 South Delaware Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204source10AM - 2PMsourceSunday onlysourceTakes reservationssourceSeafoodsource4.5source406source
4050 Dandy Trail, Indianapolis, IN 46254source10AM - 2PMsourceSunday onlysourceTakes reservationssourceSeafoodsource4.2source1,839source
2721 East 86th Street Ste 120, Indianapolis, IN 46240source7AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceTakes reservationssourceAmericansource4.5source287source
1609 North Lynhurst Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46224source8AM - 3PMsourceSaturday and SundaysourceTakes reservationssourceCafe & bakerysource4.3source150source
1435 East 86th Street Ste B, Indianapolis, IN 46240source7AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceWalk-in onlysourceBreakfastsource4source160source
830 Massachusetts Avenue Ste 1480, Indianapolis, IN 46204source10AM - 2PMsourceSaturday and SundaysourceTakes reservationssourceSeafoodsource4.6source627source
9134 Otis Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46216source8AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceCafe & bakerysource4.5source413source
6336 Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220source7:30AM - 4PMsourceTakes reservationssourceLatin Americansource4.6source184source
635 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46204source10AM - 1PMsourceSunday onlysourceBar & pubsource4.4source349source
7235 North Keystone Avenue Ste H, Indianapolis, IN 46240source8AM - 3PMsourceTakes reservationssourceBreakfastsource3.9source104source
314 North Delaware Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204source7AM - 3PMsourceEvery daysourceBreakfastsource4.3source459source

Our take

For the best-reviewed plate in town, Lincoln Square Pancake House on Market Street and Rosa's All Day Cafe on the northwest side both hold a 4.8 rating on Restaurantji, and Cafe Patachou downtown sits just behind at 4.7 across 640 ratings. All three are breakfast and lunch cafes that open by 8AM on Sunday and close at 3PM.

The real split in this table is between those daytime cafes and the restaurants that run a separate brunch service. Lincoln Square, RIZE Ironworks and The Roost open at 7AM on Sunday and serve every day of the week, while Commission Row and Rick's Cafe Boatyard serve brunch only on Sunday from 10AM to 2PM, and Ralston's Drafthouse only from 10AM to 1PM. If you want to book, Commission Row, The Fountain Room and RIZE take reservations; The Roost, Good Morning Mama's and Garden Table, which takes no brunch bookings on weekends, do not.

Our picks

  • Highest rated downtown: Lincoln Square Pancake House (Market Street). A 4.8 rating from 197 ratings, open 7AM to 3PM on Sunday and every other day of the week.
  • Most-reviewed brunch cafe: Cafe Patachou (Downtown). 640 ratings behind its 4.7, with Sunday hours of 8AM to 3PM across from the State Capitol.
  • Dressy brunch you can book: Commission Row. Takes reservations for a Sunday-only seafood brunch from 10AM to 2PM, rated 4.5.
  • Earliest start with a reservation: RIZE Ironworks. Opens at 7AM on Sunday, serves every day, and takes reservations, rated 4.5 from 287 ratings.
  • Brunch on the water: Rick's Café Boatyard. Sunday-only brunch from 10AM to 2PM at Eagle Creek, with the most ratings here at 1839.

All-day breakfast cafe or a Sunday brunch service

At the breakfast and lunch cafes the Sunday menu is the everyday menu: Lincoln Square Pancake House, Wild Eggs downtown, The Roost in Nora and RIZE Ironworks open at 7AM, Cafe Patachou, Cafe Audrey at Fort Ben and Rosa's at 8AM, and all of them close around 3PM. That suits an early start and a quick table turn, but it also means the Sunday crowd lands on a regular kitchen.

The rest treat brunch as an event with a fixed window. Commission Row and Rick's Cafe Boatyard serve it on Sunday only from 10AM to 2PM, The Fountain Room on Saturday and Sunday from 10AM to 2PM, The Oakmont on both weekend days from 10AM to 3PM for guests 21 and older only, and Ralston's Drafthouse squeezes it into 10AM to 1PM. Arlene's by Milktooth sits in between, open 10AM to 3PM five days a week from Thursday through Monday, so a Monday brunch is an option there.

Booking a table or waiting for one

Nine of these take reservations, including Commission Row, The Fountain Room, RIZE Ironworks, Borage, Dad's Kitchen Indy, Huevos etc and Tupelo Honey, and that is the safer bet for a group or a set time. Three say plainly that they do not: The Roost does not accept reservations for regular dining, Good Morning Mama's seats first come, first served and only once the whole party is there, and Garden Table books brunch on weekdays only, so a Sunday table there is first come, first served.

For Arlene's by Milktooth, Cafe Patachou, Lincoln Square, Rosa's, Cafe Audrey, Ralston's and Wild Eggs, the pages we read did not say either way, so the Reservations cell is blank. Wild Eggs offers an online waitlist instead. Call ahead or check their booking page before a busy Sunday.

Downtown and Mass Ave or out in the neighborhoods

Ten spots are downtown or on Mass Ave, from Cafe Patachou, Lincoln Square and Wild Eggs near the Capitol and Monument Circle to The Fountain Room, Garden Table, The Oakmont and Ralston's on or near Massachusetts Avenue, where street parking can mean a wait. The north side has Good Morning Mama's on 54th Street, Dad's Kitchen Indy, Huevos etc on Keystone, and RIZE and The Roost on 86th Street; Borage in Speedway, Rosa's on Westlane Road and Rick's at Eagle Creek cover the west, and Cafe Audrey is out at Fort Benjamin Harrison.

The options in detail

Arlene's by Milktooth

The Fletcher Place brunch room that put Indianapolis brunch on the map, now operating as Arlene's by Milktooth: the same brunch menu plus Southern-style meat-and-three plates. Reviewers single out the biscuit and grits with egg and bacon, the french toast and the sausage casserole, and call the portions generous. Some find it pricey for brunch and point out the automatic gratuity and service charge.

Cafe Patachou (Downtown)

The downtown outpost of the Indianapolis cafe that has been a brunch habit since 1989, across from the State Capitol. Reviewers praise the omelettes, the lox, the croissant French toast and the coconut bread, and like that the coffee is self-serve. It is often noted as a safe pick for people with food allergies, and service stays quick even on busy race weekends.

Tupelo Honey Southern Kitchen & Bar

A Southern kitchen in the CityWay building downtown, serving brunch, lunch and dinner from one all-day kitchen. Reviewers rave about the biscuits, the fried chicken brined for 18 hours, fried green tomatoes and goat cheese grits, with mimosas a brunch favorite. The decor gets compliments, but several reviews mention slow service when it is busy.

The Oakmont

A downtown bar and restaurant near Mass Ave whose weekend brunch reviewers describe as a party: a DJ, cocktails and a lively crowd. It admits guests 21 and older only, so it is not a family brunch. Favorites include the breakfast Buddha bowl, carne asada tacos, fried deviled eggs and truffle fries. The music can be loud for a quiet catch-up, and its small free lot fills up.

Garden Table (Mass Ave)

A juice bar and eatery on Mass Ave with a full bar, built around fresh, lighter brunch plates. Reviewers recommend the Garden Benedict on grain toast with avocado spread, the smoked salmon hash, the power bowl and the chorizo omelette, plus fresh juices and specialty lattes. Street parking on Mass Ave can mean a wait.

Good Morning Mama's

A 1950s-themed breakfast spot just south of Broad Ripple that locals treat as a weekend ritual. Reviewers praise the pancakes with blueberries or chocolate chips, crispy hash browns, the tomato Florentine and the Full Boat platter, and say the mimosas are made with good bubbly. Parking is limited, and parties are seated only when everyone has arrived.

Lincoln Square Pancake House (Market Street)

The Market Street location of a local pancake-house chain, a short walk from downtown hotels. Reviewers like the generous portions, the homemade corned beef hash and plates like the Country Lady and The Entire Farm, and say the pancakes are good even without syrup. Prices are low for downtown, and there are healthier choices beside the classics.

Rosa's All Day Cafe

A family-owned breakfast and brunch cafe on the northwest side, often called a hidden gem. Reviewers single out the cinnamon roll French toast, sweet cream cheese pancakes and the country fried steak skillet, with big portions and easy parking. The room itself is plain, and service gets mixed reviews when it is packed on a Sunday.

Commission Row

An upscale raw bar, steak and seafood restaurant downtown that serves brunch only on Sunday. Reviewers mention the lobster roll, oysters and an impressive wine and cocktail list, and the windows look onto the ice rink in winter. It is the priciest table here, and the oysters in particular are called expensive.

Rick's Café Boatyard

A waterside restaurant on Eagle Creek Reservoir on the far west side, with a Sunday brunch menu of skillets, biscuits and gravy and eggs dishes. Reviewers come for the sunset and reservoir view, the crab cakes and the steak and seafood. Outdoor seating is limited to the bar area, so ask for a window if the patio is full.

RIZE Ironworks

A modern breakfast and brunch restaurant at the Ironworks Hotel on 86th Street, using ingredients from Indiana farms and baking in house. Reviewers recommend the Farm Eggs plate with a griddled English muffin, the goose sausage, the breakfast burritos and the seasonal pop tarts, and say substitutions are welcome. Prices are described as fair for the quality.

Borage

A cafe, bakery and small market in Speedway on the west side, with a sit-down brunch service on weekends. Reviewers love the soft cinnamon roll, the coffee and the espresso martinis, and describe the room as cozy. Some mention waiting to be seated even with open tables, and prices that run a little high.

The Roost (Nora)

A neighborhood breakfast and lunch spot in Nora on the north side, with a summer patio beside a bike trail. Reviewers mention quick seating, cheerful service and plenty of parking, and order the breaded pork eggs Benedict, the build-your-own omelette and the corn casserole. It works well for large groups.

The Fountain Room

A supper club in the Bottleworks District on Mass Ave that serves brunch on Saturday and Sunday. Reviewers recommend the brie brulee and focaccia, and at brunch the cinnamon roll, omelette and breakfast sandwich, with cocktails to match. It is a dressier room, and guests often book it for birthdays and anniversaries.

Cafe Audrey at Fort Ben

A breakfast and lunch cafe at Fort Benjamin Harrison on the northeast side, with brunch cocktails including a mimosa flight. Reviewers praise the vegetable eggs Benedict, the potato soup and the large breakfast portions, and say it is kid friendly with high chairs. It can get loud when busy, and some find prices on the higher side.

Dad's Kitchen Indy

A Broad Ripple cafe with a Peruvian- and Latin-inspired breakfast menu beside diner standards. Reviewers recommend the chilaquiles, chorizo burrito and veggie tacos, and the horchata coffee and lattes are a standout. There is plenty of parking and a kids menu, and it has room for groups.

Ralston's Drafthouse

A friendly Mass Ave drafthouse that serves a scratch-made brunch for a short window on Sunday morning. Its own menu points to the angel biscuits and gravy and the Elvis French toast, and reviewers describe a welcoming, inclusive bar crowd and a strong draft list. Service reviews are mixed, though recent ones say it improved under new ownership.

Huevos etc Breakfast & Brunch

A north-side breakfast and brunch spot on Keystone Avenue known for its old-school R&B soundtrack and party energy. Reviewers recommend the shrimp and grits with catfish, the country fried steak with eggs and the stuffed French toast. Some find the music too loud and the service uneven near closing.

Wild Eggs (Downtown)

The downtown branch of a Louisville breakfast and brunch chain, in the former Indianapolis Star building on Pulliam Square a few steps from Monument Circle, and the only Wild Eggs inside the city proper. Reviewers praise the chicken and waffles, the carnitas Benedict and Kalamity Katie's Border Benedict, along with fresh-squeezed orange juice, spiked coffees and gluten-free and keto choices. Its page offers an online waitlist to join before a busy weekend, and a few diners say the restrooms could be cleaner.

How we researched this

We read each restaurant's Restaurantji listing for its address, Sunday hours, food categories and rating with its count, and each restaurant's own website for its brunch window, the days brunch is served and whether it takes reservations, recording every value with the line it came from. The set was built from local brunch guides and checked place by place for Sunday service. We left out Livery, which opens at 4PM on Sunday, Parkside Public House, whose site announces its final brunch and closing, and Sully's Grill, Taxman CityWay, The Eagle, Spoke & Steele and Shelby Street Tavern, whose pages did not confirm a Sunday brunch. The Oakmont's own site could not be read, so its brunch window comes from its AAA listing.

Restaurantji only gives prices as dollar-sign bands, so there is no price column. A blank cell means no page we read stated that detail. Brunch hours and holiday closures change, so confirm with the restaurant before you go.

Related comparisons