Best Payroll Software
17 payroll services compared on starting price, pricing model, tax filing, contractor plans and time tracking, from Gusto and ADP to Patriot and Deel. Read our take
At a glance
| Option | Starting price | Pricing model | Type | Tax filing | Contractor payments | Time tracking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $49/month plus $6 per employee (Simple plan)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Contractor-only plansource | Higher-tier plans onlysource | |
| $50/month plus $7 per employee (Workforce Payroll plan)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Contractor-only plansource | Higher-tier plans onlysource | |
| Quote only (one reviewer was quoted $49/month plus $2.50 per employee per weekly pay run)source | Custom quotesource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| $39/month plus $5 per employee (Essentials; higher plans by quote)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| $49/month plus $6 per workersource | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| From $8 per employee per month plus a monthly base fee (custom quote)source | Custom quotesource | All-in-one HR and payrollsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| Full Service $37/month plus $5 per worker; Basic (you file taxes) $17/month plus $4 per workersource | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Cheaper plan where you file yourselfsource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| $35/month plus $6 per person paid (contractor-only: $6 per person)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Contractor-only plansource | Imports hours from another appsource | |
| $29/month plus $7 per employee (Full Service)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Cheaper plan where you file yourselfsource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| $40/month plus $6 per employee and $6 per contractor paid (US)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | ||
| PEO from $79 per employee per month; payroll-only plan $50/month plus $8 per employeesource | Per person, no base feesource | PEO (co-employment)source | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| Quote onlysource | Custom quotesource | All-in-one HR and payrollsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| Quote only (plus a one-time implementation fee)source | Custom quotesource | All-in-one HR and payrollsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Paid add-onsource | |
| $49/month plus $6 per active employee (first 6 months free)source | Base fee plus per personsource | Payroll for small businessessource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid inside a payroll plansource | Includedsource | |
| $49 per contractor per month; employees abroad (EOR) from $599 per monthsource | Per person, no base feesource | Global payroll and EORsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Contractor-only plansource | Includedsource | |
| $29 per contractor per month; payroll for your own entities from $19 per employee; EOR from $599source | Per person, no base feesource | Global payroll and EORsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Contractor-only plansource | Imports hours from another appsource | |
| Quote onlysource | Custom quotesource | All-in-one HR and payrollsource | Files taxes for you on every plansource | Paid add-onsource |
Our take
For most small US businesses the answer is Gusto: $49 a month plus $6 per employee on its Simple plan, taxes filed for you on every plan, and a separate contractor-only plan if you pay freelancers. If the bill matters most, Patriot Payroll is the cheapest published price here, at $37 a month plus $5 per worker with tax filing, or $17 plus $4 if you file the taxes yourself.
The bigger split is what kind of provider you need. Ten of these 17 are payroll services built for small businesses, most with a starting price you can look up before talking to sales. Rippling, Paycor, Paycom and Paylocity are full HR suites priced through a sales quote, Justworks is a PEO that co-employs your staff, and Deel and Remote exist to pay people in other countries.
Our picks
- Best overall for a small team: Gusto. $49 a month plus $6 per employee, taxes filed on every plan, and a contractor-only plan at $35 plus $6 per worker.
- Lowest published price: Patriot Payroll. Full Service is $37 a month plus $5 per worker, and Basic Payroll, where you file taxes yourself, is $17 plus $4.
- Best if you already use QuickBooks: QuickBooks Workforce (formerly QuickBooks Payroll). $50 a month plus $7 per employee, with payroll that feeds your QuickBooks books and a separate Contractor Payments plan.
- Best for hourly shift workers: Homebase Payroll. The one small-business payroll service here with time tracking included: hours come from the Homebase time clock, for $49 a month plus $6 per active employee.
- Best for paying people abroad: Remote. No base fee, contractors from $29 each per month in 190+ countries, and payroll for your own foreign entities from $19 per employee.
Published price or sales quote
Most of the small-business services print a base fee plus a fee per person paid, so you can price them yourself: Square Payroll at $35 plus $6, SurePayroll at $29 plus $7, Wave Payroll at $40 plus $6 per employee and $6 per contractor, OnPay at $49 plus $6, and Paychex Flex's Essentials plan at $39 plus $5. RUN Powered by ADP, Rippling, Paycor, Paycom and Paylocity ask you to request a quote; Rippling at least states a floor of $8 per employee a month plus a base fee, and the only figure for ADP comes from a quote one reviewer received.
Read the starting prices as an entry point, not a total. Gusto and QuickBooks Workforce charge more on the plans that add time tracking or HR tools, add-ons raise the bill at most of the rest, and Paycom's quote carries a one-time implementation fee.
Filing payroll taxes yourself to save money
Every provider in the table files and pays payroll taxes for you on its main plan. Only two sell a cheaper plan where that job is yours: Patriot Payroll's Basic plan at $17 a month plus $4 per worker, and SurePayroll's No Tax Filing plan. That saving is real for a one- or two-person payroll, but a missed deposit costs more than the difference, so most owners take the full-service plan.
Paying contractors and tracking hours
If you only pay 1099 contractors, five services sell a plan just for that: Square Payroll at $6 per person paid with no base fee, Gusto at $35 plus $6, QuickBooks Workforce, and for contractors abroad, Remote from $29 and Deel from $49 per contractor a month. At the other services with a stated answer, Paychex Flex included, contractors are paid inside a regular payroll plan.
Time tracking is the add-on most buyers forget. It is a paid add-on at OnPay, Patriot Payroll, SurePayroll, RUN Powered by ADP, Paychex Flex, Rippling, Justworks, Paycor, Paycom and Paylocity, and it sits on the higher plans at Gusto and QuickBooks Workforce. Homebase Payroll and Deel include it, and Square Payroll and Remote pull hours in from their own timecard and timesheet tools.
PEO or global employer of record
Justworks works differently from a payroll service: as a PEO it becomes the co-employer of your staff, runs payroll, files taxes and manages benefits, priced per employee from $79 a month. Deel and Remote go further and can legally employ someone in a country where you have no company, which costs far more per person. A business with only US staff rarely needs either.
The options in detail
Gusto
The payroll service most small-business reviewers treat as the default pick: full-service payroll with unlimited pay runs, tax filing, onboarding and benefits in one clean app. It is one of the few with a cheap contractor-only plan, and it can pay contractors in other countries. The starter Simple plan leaves out time tracking and hiring tools, so hourly teams usually end up on the pricier Plus plan.
QuickBooks Workforce (formerly QuickBooks Payroll)
Intuit renamed QuickBooks Payroll to QuickBooks Workforce and folded in time tracking, hiring and HR workflows. Its real draw is the link to QuickBooks accounting, so payroll lands in your books with no export. Reviewers note it gets expensive as headcount grows, and time tracking and local tax filing need the Premium or Elite plan. There is also a separate plan for businesses that only pay contractors.
RUN Powered by ADP
ADP's small-business payroll, with a long list of add-ons (benefits, workers' comp, time tracking, PEO and international payroll) to grow into. ADP does not publish prices, and reviewers mark it down for that and for pricing by pay run rather than unlimited runs. It suits a business that expects to scale and wants one vendor for the long haul.
Paychex Flex
Paychex's payroll platform, built to run from a one-person company up to large employers, and rated well by reviewers for service and support. Only the entry Essentials plan has a published price; the rest are quoted. Time tracking, benefits and HR help are paid add-ons, and there is no cheaper plan for paying contractors only. Some users report trouble reaching support on tax issues.
OnPay
A transparent, one-price payroll service: everything in the core plan, all 50 states included, and federal, state and local tax filings handled for you. HR tools and time tracking are optional add-ons with their own small base fee. OnPay offers the first month free and free migration from another provider, and reviewers like it for straightforward small teams that want few surprises on the bill.
Rippling
An all-in-one HR, IT and payroll platform where every product connects, so hours, benefits deductions and new hires flow into payroll automatically. It can pay people in many countries, which makes it a common pick for companies planning to hire abroad. The catch is cost: pricing is modular and quoted, you must buy the core platform before any module, and very small teams often find it more than they need.
Patriot Payroll
The budget pick in most roundups, with published prices for two plans: Basic Payroll, where you file the taxes yourself, and Full Service, where Patriot files and deposits them. Unlimited payrolls, free direct deposit, a contractor portal and US-based support come with both. Time and attendance and HR software are cheap add-ons. It is plainer than Gusto or Rippling, with few HR tools beyond the basics.
Square Payroll
Payroll built into the Square ecosystem, so restaurants and shops already on Square POS can pull timecards and tips straight into each pay run. The full-service plan files federal and state taxes at no extra charge, and a contractor-only plan charges just a fee per person paid. It is less compelling for a business that does not use Square for sales or scheduling.
SurePayroll
Paychex's low-cost online payroll for very small teams and household employers, with unlimited pay runs, free 2-day direct deposit and live phone support. A cheaper No Tax Filing plan exists if you want to file and deposit taxes yourself. Watch the extras: year-end W-2 and 1099 forms are billed separately, and multi-state payroll and a time clock integration cost more each month.
Wave Payroll
The payroll add-on to Wave's accounting software, aimed at very small businesses that already keep their books in Wave. It pays employees and contractors, automatically files and pays state and federal payroll taxes, and posts journal entries to your books. Every contractor paid counts toward the monthly fee, and it has no time tracking of its own.
Justworks
A PEO: Justworks becomes the co-employer of your staff, running payroll, filing and paying taxes, and managing benefits. Unusually for a PEO, it publishes its prices, and it also sells a payroll-only plan for businesses that do not want co-employment. Time tracking is a paid add-on, and it is aimed at small to midsize firms rather than large ones.
Paycor
A human capital management platform that puts payroll, HR, onboarding, benefits and talent tools in one system, aimed mainly at companies past about 50 employees. Every plan includes tax filing and unlimited payroll, but pricing is by quote only and time tracking, scheduling and benefits administration cost extra. Reviewers rate its feature depth well and mark it down for opaque pricing.
Paycom
Single-database HR and payroll software for growing and midsize to large companies, known for Beti, which has employees review and approve their own paychecks before payroll runs. Pricing is a custom quote with a one-time implementation fee, and anything beyond core payroll, including time tracking and benefits administration, is an add-on. It is more system than a 10-person business usually needs.
Homebase Payroll
Payroll as an add-on to Homebase's scheduling and time clock app, built for hourly teams that clock in and out. Hours come straight from the time clock, and tax filings, W-2s and 1099s are included, with unlimited payroll runs. It makes the most sense if you already schedule shifts in Homebase; on its own it is a plain payroll service.
Deel
A global hiring and payroll platform for paying contractors and employees in other countries, including as an employer of record where you have no local company. Contractor payments are priced per contractor, and employing someone abroad through its EOR costs far more per person. It also runs a US PEO. For a team that is entirely in the US, a domestic payroll service is usually simpler and cheaper.
Remote
A global payroll, employer-of-record and contractor platform with published per-person prices and no base fee. It can pay contractors in 190+ countries, run payroll through companies you already own abroad, or employ people for you where you have no entity. Like Deel, it is built for international teams rather than a business with only US staff.
Paylocity
A cloud payroll and HR suite built for midsize and larger companies, sold as a custom package: you start with payroll and add modules such as recruiting and time and attendance as you grow. Reviewers single out its payroll and time-tracking tools, the expense reimbursement built into payroll, and a dedicated account manager for every client. The catch is that pricing is only available by quote, and the full platform is more than a very small business usually needs.
How we researched this
We read each provider's own payroll and pricing pages and, where a vendor does not publish a figure or blocks automated reading (Gusto, Intuit, ADP, Justworks and Paylocity), detailed reviews on Fit Small Business and Business.org, and recorded every value with the sentence it came from. Prices are worded as each source prints them, so the starting price column is not comparable row to row.
The set covers the payroll services most often recommended for US small businesses, the HR suites midsize companies compare, one PEO and two global providers. Roll by ADP was left out because its pages could not be read reliably, and salon and enterprise payroll have their own pages. A blank cell means no source we read stated it: Wave Payroll has no time tracking value and Paylocity has no contractor payments value. Prices and promotions change often, so confirm the current offer with the provider before you sign up.















